Wins should be absolute
A karate teacher had once told me, "if you're a good blue belt, you'll be a good brown belt. If you're a good brown belt, you'll be a good shodan."
This is the philosophy of being so good that there's no question, no contest, about "passing a bar". If you have to ask where the bar is exactly, you're optimizing for the wrong thing, and falling victim of Goodhart's law.
It is a question of quality, of rounded-out knowledge, of self-confidence. It translates well in many ways for me into any kind of evaluation in business or personal life. It's asserting that luck's role should be minimized; that you haven't won unless your skill, or proposal, or product, is so obviously better than the competition that there's no contest whatsoever.
It's the principle of "fuck yes" or "no" applied outside the relationship context. A product that's borderline better than others is meh. A product that has extremely clear advantages has no competition at all.
So, don't just "pass the bar". KPIs are okay, and you should measure them, but is being 1% better what you can be proud of?